I still have an affinity for punk rock music although I'm close to being in my 30's. There is just something so wonderful and powerful in a 45 second, super-fast power chord filled rock song. Just seems to get me moving. But, I realize that many people don't listen to punk rock and don't understand what makes the difference between a good punk rock song and a bad punk rock song. As with any other genre of music people have varying opinions about good vs. bad songs, and you will get different answers depending and who you ask. For the benefit of the unknowing, I will give my breakdown here.
Now, I'm not going to go into a diatribe about how in the 70s punk rock rose from the ashes as a backlash to disco, but to fully understand all the things that fans love about punk rock you first must understand the range that punk rock covers, and the different forms the music can take that are deemed acceptable to pass as punk rock. Punk rock can be fun or harsh, it can be silly or angry, it can even be poppy or politically charged. Punk rock can be simply guitar, bass and drums--or it can include other instruments like horns, stand up basses, keyboards, and even the violin. The one thing in common across all punk rock songs is the crunching guitar and fast tempo.
Of course, not all punk rock fans love all the forms punk rock can take, or the topics that the bands choose to sing about. Some prefer the angry and political punk rock bands
because they sort of make a declaration of their unhappiness with the status q
uo. Others prefer the lighter pop punk sound
because to them its more fun. Its these differences in each individual that determine what makes a good vs. a bad punk rock song.
Doesn't sound very profound does it? That's because its not. Punk rock is no different than any other form of music when it comes to why people like a certain song or not--it comes down to movement. Not movement in terms of dancing, head bobbing, etc. What I mean is that it depends on whether the song moves people internally, as with any great song. Let's use a classic rock example of a song that is universally accepted as a great song: Hey Jude by the Beatles. Why do people love that song? What is it about that song that makes it so popular? It's because it moves people--the message moves people, the rhythm moves people, the
catchiness of the song moves people. It's very memorable; people tend to remember when they first heard it, and when they hear it for the first time in a long time they suddenly remember the words and they have fun singing along with it. Great punk rock songs are no different, but think about the challenge of punk rock bands to write songs considered great.
Have you ever noticed that there are a LOT of punk rock bands out there--so many that even the hardcore punk rock fans can't keep up with all the new bands. That's because, generally speaking, punk rock is easier to play than other forms of music. I mean let's face it, most punk rock songs are a series of power chords repeated at a fast pace with mid to heavy distortion adding such a bite to the music that sometimes it's hard to make out the words. Even if bands screw up, a lot of the time it isn't noticeable. And assuming bands can put together lyrics to lay over the track that sound decent, they can produce a lot of songs in a short amount of time. But despite this fact, punk rock songs have a groove to them that fans like, or don't like. The great punk rock songs have become great because they moved a lot of fans at the same time. Sounds crazy to the untrained ear, but punk rock takes a lot of talent to be good at.
That's what I love about it. In my opinion, the great punk rock bands are the ones that make so much out of so little. I use the phrase "so little" because most punk rock songs are so short that there isn't much time for them to become elaborate expressions of music. A lot of them don't have guitar solo's, a lot of them have a few lines repeated several times, and as I said above typically the music is "easy" to play. The great punk rock songs are the ones that come across your speakers with a synergy that makes them sound like they are so much more than they are. Yes, I do appreciate the rawness in the crunching guitars and the off-pitch vocals. I do get hyped up by the speed of the music. But its the idea of so much from so little that fascinates me about punk rock (its also why I love The White Stripes, but that's for another time). I will not list my favorite punk bands here--rather I will write about them as time goes on. And maybe I'll post about why I believe that some of the best song writers in music today are coming from punk rock and country.